next »

[onemanarmy]

only good memories for this guy! -1

[muskita]

http://dotapickup.com/parser/view_replay.php?file=1298038796.w3g

here a replay where he also backdoored

[Grnn]

nope but as i said, ive not watched the replay - mb the supporters kept zeus away from creeps so he could freefarm without getting harassed? i dunno. Mb he lacks eperience and thinks "wow freefarm i should rush relic!11" still dunno cuz i cant watch the replay from here. Im not defending him its just i think you couldve told him in game what u expected from him for better results - obviously he shouldve gone for treads/1-2bands/stick/roh to rape zeus solo so the supporters could move but is it so hard to give ppl some guidelines if they seem inexperienced?

well isnt that exactly what ppl shoud have in XP?? experience?????

[Lord]

I don't know this player at allso I won't vote on anything.
But going naked diffu on naga and not getting anything else deserves a ban or something, by the comments in this thread you can see he isn't a new/unexperienced. So imo he should get atleast a warning/note somewhere that if he does somth like this again he gets an xp ban for some days. Serious gaming = serious items.

[tt-denvildehest]

@Falling

for me i rather have a naked hero on a skilled player, than a geared lowskiller.

Everyone should do his best in Xp games and you are basicly stating that rules should be different for skilled players and its acceptable for them to go for stupid items because they are skilled is exactly the opposite of what XP should be about.

I really dont get you, in the other thread you state that its unacceptable to go boots stick eaglehorn on sniper and in this thread you defend naga for doing a naked diffusal, which is way worse and that you can hopefully realise.

And you are even patronizing me, simply for stating this, when its clear you are not being very objective in these two cases. You state that the difference is that the other thread was a banrequest and assasin was early applicant. Guess what, so was darker-fear. And you still deny assasin xp for doing something that is identical.

@Topic
Well after this thread it kindda seems he got his act together and realised XP isn't the place for stupid itembuilds. Maybe a removal is too drastic, but I really hate to see actions like these go unpunished just because people are more skilled or liked, rules applies for everyone, especially in XP, but I guess there is nothing to be done for now.

[Snut]

http://dotapickup.com/parser/view_replay.php?file=1298038796.w3g

here a replay where he also backdoored

sadly this request got denied muskita, so dont state wrong facts here pls.

[muskita]

http://dotapickup.com/parser/view_replay.php?file=1298038796.w3g

here a replay where he also backdoored

denied so doesnt count...

[TaurenTimmy]

So im writing again in this tread, because i also ban requested someone who did almost the same as this guy, and i can say i think this guy should get another chance and not get removed, and rather get a seriouswarning! or minor ban for pulling this off in a XP game!

Naga farms really bad on his free farming lane, but even though he farms bad he can buy hood directly at min 8 (got 2100 gold) which would really help him in this game, but he doesnt even buy ONE single item, i mean not a single stick vs zeus!!!!!!!!! seriously ??? XP game???? and then buys diffusal at 16 mins. If he would get proper items he would RAPE zeus and his farm would be much better.

If anyone says that kotl or any other hero took his farm early, then they haven't seen replay, or if they even try to defend this, gameruin by naga they should be totally ignored in this tread!

Seriously guys this aint euro!

Give this guy a warning or minor ban, but remember to give him a second chance in XP.

***SilversunPickup, mmmbop and sundelin take a look at the replay one more time.

[jOOOEY]

+1

[MiekarN-Jojjeowner]

No matter who fucked up the game. Naked diffu, no items before min 22 and 150 cs after 52 min is not acceptable.

Edit: For anyone who doesnt believe it and doesnt wanna watch the replay, just look at his items order from the parser

Better then you in most games in my opinion, maybe u should make a request to remove urself ?

[Spere]

Fake and gaaaaaaaaay.

Also a good player, hence unsupport for remove.

[Spere]

Lokked.

[Lord]

Seriously guys this aint euro!

Give this guy a warning or minor ban, but remember to give him a second chance in XP.

+1.
Unsupport remove, support short xp ban.