next »

[Anthrax.Pezer]

I think it would be good if you put a minimum of xp or rank on adding+c. Alot of 800~ xp ppl adding like captain and its not very fun to be in that team facinga  captain of around 1300~. I'm thinking 1000+ as a required xp.
I'm one of those 800 xpers, and I know i got this xp for a reason. And its not bad luck.

sincerely yours, Pezer!

Appriciate opinions and ideas about this :)

[Tommel]

add for +c on your own if u dont weant to have a bad captain.
I think its good because it is the only chance to be captain if u are below 1k points atm while you can only be challenged if u are above 1k

-->> disagree

[CrackAttack]

hm i know some guys with low xp but good cap abilities. even if you suck as player u can still be nice  cap.

[ProduceFootmen]

hm i know some guys with low xp but good cap abilities. even if you suck as player u can still be nice  cap.

also i know players who totally overestimate their capability as captain AND as player and still add+c all the time... we can turn it the other way round too ;)

[GAZiDAKUN]

also i know players who totally overestimate their capability as captain AND as player and still add+c all the time... we can turn it the other way round too ;)

+1 Imo even if there is bad luck the xp still reflects the player

[wizz]

Still, I don't see any problem in adding +c .

- Case 1 : a player with low xp adds +c and you're saying " FF, he sucks, he shouldn't be cap"
=> Go add +c yourself ? If you feel like you're better it's the best way to handle this


- Case 2 : all the guys who added +c finished in the same team except for the player with low xp who added +c / "FF i'm in his team again "
=> Again go add+c yourself :)

However its rare that people with high xp don't add +c in add1. They don't want to depends on others for picks and they're prolly right :) Though even good pickers are outpicked from time to time.

[para1]

besides normally in xp there is much more "outplay" rather than "outpick".

[Charoxis]

i dont know; you dont want to understand him or you really dont understand what he means: hes claiming about some "wannabe"-cpts who add +c; and if you say "add yourself" +c this is the answer: Mostly they think they are no good cpt on their own. but they know if this cpt. is goin to pick they will gonna loose nearly for sure. So he asked for some req. to be able to do +c-add.

Imo the problem is you cant seperate "good" and "bad" - "lower xp"-cpts. The bad ones have to face their picks sucks mostly so they stop to add +c. I just remember Slimy e.g. . He added +c mostly; meanwhile he stopped it since a long time (even if I dont know the reason I think it was people claimed about his picks).

All in all i think you cant find a good solution to evade "bad" cpts. just if you dont add if you dont trust the +c-added people;

[para1]

maybe get some serparate stats for +c guys in add1 first. if someone always adds +c and nearly always loses (lets say 80% loose), there is a huge chance that he simply sucks @being capt. so maybe put it in this direction?

[ProduceFootmen]

maybe get some serparate stats for +c guys in add1 first. if someone always adds +c and nearly always loses (lets say 80% loose), there is a huge chance that he simply sucks @being capt. so maybe put it in this direction?

mby just increase the pointloss for the captain, lets so to 25 instead of 20 ? (debatable ofc)

[SilversunPickup]

Ye and then you get famous XP players in your team(no names) who increase your chances to lose immense ... no thank you.

[Jookie]

There is a set prerequiment for that of judging a captains skill, since it infers that you indeed possess the skill to perfom the captains task yourself.

Incidently, you do not qualify as a judge unless you're an excelling figure in that which you're trying to judge.

For the slightly less intelligent: The deaf can not teach, nor lay judgement on music.

Ergo this thread, made by a person insisting on being a bad captain, is completely void and irreversibly contradictory.

My opinion on the subject, by now, should be rather clear.

[Charoxis]

You dont like people who are added? -> Don't add; there wont be a "no Bud_Spencer game" e.g. :D you know what i mean ;)

Even "famous xp players" should know about their picking strength ;) But good idea to think about percentage winratio while being cpt or something. (complicated to manage? dunno im noob)

But Footies idea is kinda bad imo. 5xp wont stop them to add+c, neither 10xp.

[JipJap]

There is a set prerequiment for that of judging a captains skill, since it infers that you indeed possess the skill to perfom the captains task yourself.

Incidently, you do not qualify as a judge unless you're an excelling figure in that which you're trying to judge.

For the slightly less intelligent: The deaf can not teach, nor lay judgement on music.

Ergo this thread, made by a person insisting on being a bad captain, is completely void and irreversibly contradictory.

My opinion on the subject, by now, should be rather clear.

You don't need to be a good football player to judge football.
You don't need to be a musician to lay judgement on music.
You dom't need to be a good cook to judge if food tastes good.

[GAZiDAKUN]

You don't need to be a good football player to judge football.
You don't need to be a musician to lay judgement on music.
You dom't need to be a good cook to judge if food tastes good.

Thats true,it's not like he was talking about a subject he don't know anything about.
And come on how can you be a good capitain when u got like 800 xp,it's obvious that you fail imo.
Plus I don't understand why people say "add+c yourself" since Anthrax.Pezer stated that he knew he wasn't that good to pick, all he says is that some shouldn't add as capt because they ruin games with bad picks/plays(because this capt are often picking the carrys)
But i think the only solution to this is only to dodge.